C Walker Cooper Gets the nod over Ernie Lombardi
1B Johnny Mize Would have been Hank Greenberg if not for the war
2B Joe Gordon Barely edges out Bobby Doerr
3B Bob Elliott over Ken Keltner
SS Lou Boudreau Beats out Johnny Pesky
OF Ted Williams
OF Joe DiMaggio
OF Stan Musial
U Ralph Kiner
RHP Bob Feller
LHP Hal Newhouser
Sorry bro, Hank Greenberg was STILL waaaay better than Mize.
ReplyDeleteActually they were quite comparable seeing as how they finished their careers with the same OPS+, and Mize maintained it over an additional 1,200 plate appearances.
ReplyDeleteBecause of the war, Hammerin' Hank played just three full seasons during the '40s so it doesn't make sense to include him here.